| 55 Meter Dash | |||
| Scott Foster | 6.53 | 1989 | Shore Conference – 1st |
| Mickey Shupin | 6.58 | 2002 | Molly Stanner Games – tied 2nd |
| Bob Gifford | 6.67 | 1985 | Shore Conference – 4th |
| Rick Wenner | 6.67 | 1991 | |
| Brian Garibay | 6.72 | 1990 | |
| Dan Paff | 6.75 | 1989 | |
| Jeff Collins | 6.80 | 1994 | |
| Chevesse Covin | 6.86 | 2018 | |
| Steven Jackson | 6.92 | 2016 | |
| Anthony Gallo | 6.93 | 2002 | Molly Stanner Games |
| Russel Schwaber | 6.96 | 2001 | Shore Conference |
| 55m High Hurdles | |||
| Brian Garibay | 7.90 | 1990 | |
| Dan Heil | 7.93 | 1993 | |
| Justin Taylor | 7.95 | 1996 | |
| Mickey Shupin | 7.95 | 2001 | |
| Matthew Shatkus | 8.11 | 2002 | West Point |
| Brad Choppy | 8.14 | 1994 | |
| Kevin Daniel | 8.17 | 1995 | |
| Blake Fornarotto | 8.19 | 2002 | Monmouth County |
| Matthew Miller | 8.34 | 2017 | |
| Chris Smith | 8.36 | 2013 | |
| 200m | |||
| Robert Donofrio | 23.06 | 2003 | Hispanic Games – 8th |
| Anthony Gallo | 23.48 | 2002 | West Point – 6th |
| Drew Gerber | 24.09 | 2020 | Toms River Frosh/Novice |
| Henry Gallo | 24.23 | 1999 | Varsity Classic |
| Jake Pepe** | 25.10 | 2019 | Toms River Frosh/Novice |
| Matthew Miller | 25.14 | 2017 | Colts Neck & Friends Invitational |
| Connor Miller | 25.29 | 2010 | Shore Conference |
| Steven Jackson | 25.57 | 2018 | Colts Neck & Friends Invitational |
| Ryan Abogabal | 25.59 | 2024 | STCA Season Opener |
| Joseph Shimko | 25.67 | 2017 | Ocean Breeze Invitational |
| Aidan Denton | 25.82 | 2024 | STCA Season Opener |
| Sean Southwell | 25.97 | 2019 | Toms River Frosh/Novice |
| 400m | |||
| Matthew Shatkus | 50.6h | 2002 | Varsity Classic – 10th |
| Kris Landers | 51.04 | 2000 | Easterns – 12th |
| Terrence Maliff | 51.24 | 2010 | Meet of Champions – 19th |
| Robert Donofrio | 51.25 | 2003 | Easterns – tied 12th (Video) |
| Jeff Collins | 52.43 | 1994 | Group 2 – 2nd |
| Anthony Gallo | 53.57 | 2002 | Shore Conference – 12th |
| Blake Fornarotto | 53.73 | 2003 | Shore Conference – 7th |
| Brad Choppy | 53.77 | 1993 | |
| Casey Morton | 54.02 | 1995 | |
| Drew Gerber | 54.07 | 2020 | STCA Last Chance |
| 800m | |||
| Matthew Remishofski | 1:54.84 | 2024 | Meet of Champions – 7th |
| Eric Motzenbecker | 1:56.67 | 1999 | Meet of Champions – 1st |
| Blake Fornarotto* | 2:00.2h | 2002 | NJ Metropolitan Invitational |
| Terrence Maliff | 2:01.00 | 2010 | NJ Spiked Shoe Holiday Festival |
| Kris Landers | 2:01.06 | 2000 | Group 3 – 2nd |
| Kevin Kile* | 2:01.91 | 2017 | CJ Group 2 – 3rd |
| Joel Mosher | 2:03.6h | 1996 | |
| Oliver Langeveld** | 2:04.41 | 2024 | STCA Season Opener #1 |
| Ethan Fletcher | 2:04.67 | 2023 | Monmouth County |
| Jack Moran | 2:04.79 | 2019 | Varsity Classic |
| Matthew Shatkus | 2:05.3h | 2002 | NJ Metropolitan Invitational |
| 1600m | |||
| Eric Motzenbecker | 4:25.08c | 1999 | Easterns – 4th – race was meters (4:26.63) |
| Olivier Langeveld** | 4:27.37 | 2024 | STCA Invitational – 3rd |
| Ethan Fletcher* | 4:28.78 | 2022 | Group 2 |
| Eric Schaffer | 4:29.1h | 2005 | |
| Kris Landers | 4:33.30 | 2000 | Valentine Invitational (Drew) |
| Jack Moran | 4:33.37 | 2019 | Shore Conference |
| Jay Hagerman | 4:35.07 | 1992 | Shore Conference (4th) |
| Jozef Callano | 4:40.62 | 2023 | Shore Conference |
| Stephen Mastoridis | 4:43.92 | 2025 | Monmouth County |
| Terry Davidson | 4:44.23 | 1989 | |
| Kevin Kile | 4:44.35 | 2017 | STCA Season Opener |
| Mark Mehler | 4:46.4h | 1990 | |
| Dan Finnerty | 4:47.0h | 1996 | |
| 3200m | |||
| Matthew Remishofski | 9:39.27 | 2024 | Monmouth County – 3rd |
| Eric Motzenbecker | 9:45.25 | 1999 | Passarelli Invitational – 1st |
| Olivier Langeveld** | 9:55.39 | 2024 | SJTCA Winter Meet #14 |
| Jay Hagerman | 10:01.61 | 1992 | Monmouth County – 1st |
| Eric Schaffer | 10:07.71 | 2005 | |
| Kris Landers* | 10:12.42 | 1999 | Passarelli Invitational |
| Dan Finnerty | 10:20.54 | 1995 | Shore Conference – 5th |
| Kevin Jobes | 10:22.0h | 1992 | |
| Terry Davidson | 10:24.28 | 1989 | |
| Jozef Callano* | 10.25.26 | 2022 | CJ Group 2 – 11th |
| Charlier Mehler | 10:27.35 | 1988 | |
| Mark Lukasik | 10:33.0h | 1993 | |
| Shot Put | |||
| Dave Zaycek | 58-7 | 2004 | Meet of Champions – 1st |
| Glen Gibson | 50-1 | 1988 | |
| Chris Colangelo | 48-10 | 2003 | Monmouth County |
| Larry Cornelius | 47-5.5 | 1991 | |
| Luke Van Bethuysen | 46-1 | 2025 | Monmouth County |
| Mike Hudson | 45-2.25 | 2000 | |
| Bob Kilmurray | 44-1 | 2002 | Through The Wall (Atlantic Club) |
| John Colatrella | 43-11.25 | 2004 | Group 3 Relays |
| Louis Freda | 43-7 | 2014 | Demarest Invitational |
| Adam Merckx | 43-3 | 1993 | |
| Ethan Seelandt | 42-11.5 | 2022 | Rebel Shot/Field Series |
| High Jump | |||
| Dan Heil | 6-5 | 1993 | Monmouth County – 1st |
| Rick Wenner | 6-4 | 1992 | |
| Robbie Higgins | 6-2 | 1988 | |
| Matthew Miller | 6-0 | 2017 | |
| Jalique Cannon | 6-0 | 2017 | |
| Coley O’Brien | 5-10 | 1991 | |
| Scott Cleveland | 5-10 | 1993 | |
| Casey Morton | 5-10 | 1995 | |
| Justin Taylor | 5-10 | 1996 | |
| Riley Powers | 5-10 | 2003 | |
| Pat Gallagher | 5-10 | 2004 | Group 3 Relays |
| Matt Melton | 5-10 | 2010 | |
| Pole Vault | |||
| Chris Thomson | 13-0 | 2000 | Varsity Classic |
| Steven Jackson | 13-0 | 2018 | Meet of Champions – 11th |
| Rajan Patel** | 9-0 | 2014 | Monmouth County Relays |
| Mike Maseda* | 8-6 | 2014 | Mid Winter Classic |
| Mike Sayne*** | 8-6 | 2020 | Toms River Frosh/Novice |
